General Discussion

General DiscussionRemove "professional" players from hero rankings unless they have MIN...

Remove "professional" players from hero rankings unless they have MINIMUM 100/200 games played. in General Discussion
Wisdom

    https://www.dotabuff.com/heroes/sand-king/players

    This is a prime example of this.

    MSS played 33 games - ranked 3rd
    Maybe played 44 games - ranked 5th.
    Miposhka played 33 games - ranked 14th.

    This isn't fair, nor justified.

    ^^
      이 댓글은 중재자에 의해 삭제되었습니다.
      Riguma Borusu

        will fall on deaf ears

        Shou

          Why shud the best players be removed?
          What is your point?

          Riguma Borusu

            they are not the best at particular heroes

            DemonicTrashcan

              Sample size is key. A low number of games played doesn't lead to a very accurate reading. It should be at least 100.

              Also it's very likely/possible that a large number of those games were played while climbing mmr, as a result there will be a disproportionate amount of stomps since they are much better players than those around them.

              如果可以...放弃...

                True...some havnt played a hero in 2 years yet they rank #1...wtf is this system

                A
                A

                  ranking makes you feel you're good at a particular hero

                  Wisdom

                    Inactive players (older than 30 days) get removed from the rankings.

                    What DemonicTrashcan said is correct; although I feel like a more accurate representation would be 200 games minimum.

                    giren

                      to me 200 games is like one years of playing

                      Wisdom

                        Let's just say that 1 game = 35mins (avg).
                        10 games = 350mins
                        100 games = 3500mins

                        That's 58 hours of gameplay (excluding queues/draft etc).

                        So essentially you would need ~65-75 hours to play 100 games of 1 hero.

                        200 games = 130-150 hours which seems reasonable (to have a good understanding of hero mechanics/items/etc).

                        Wisdom

                               

                          이 코멘트는 수정되었습니다
                          quiqa

                            omg!! only rank 18 sk when should be rank 10 atleast !!! e-peen not as big as it should be fix pls!!1

                            Shou

                              Like
                              The rankings r already broken cuz they're full of 4k's and shit
                              Why wud u remove ALL pros
                              Sometimes they shudnt be there but they r usually there if they're good at the hero, and often times have more games spread on different accounts

                              MARLAN

                                Pros shouldn't be removed, but pro division should be. Just go by mmr. Add higher ratings than diamond 10.